Champions Store gets retconned

Somewhere, at some point, someone decided that microtransactions and subscription based game could actually go hand in hand. Champions Online is one of the games that have adopted this philosophy, and one of the justifications that people tend to bring up is that World of Warcraft has been doing something similar for a long time. Blizzard began with server transfers, but these days they offer both complete makeovers and even a faction change for your current characters.

Want to look like this? It costs about $3.12.

Want to look like this? It costs about $3.12.

There is a pretty major difference between World of Warcraft and Champions Online, though. Server transfers, faction changes or makeovers are not really needed in a game that only has one shard, one faction and that lets you change your characters whole appearance more or less at will. The major difference is that Champions Online offers the kind of stuff you are used to see in the item shops of free to play games, like Maple Story or Runes of Magic – new costumes, more character slots (which is also something you can buy extra in for example Guild Wars), emblems and action figures (CO’s version of vanity pets).

When I saw the store the first time, I raised an eyebrow since I didn’t think an item shop had a place in a subscription based game. Extra services, fine. Extra items, no. But the same thing can be said for SOE’s item shops in Vanguard or EverQuest II, and since Champions didn’t include things like XP-potions, I didn’t mind much. I would never pay more for costumes in CO (unless it was really, really, really cool – luckily I think CO’s character design is an atrocity towards good taste, so I doubt that would ever be an issue), and I’m fine with few character slots. The stuff in the Champions store had nothing to do with gameplay, so screw it.

Until now, when the store is suddenly offering full retcons for your characters. In more general MMO-terms, it’s a full respecc for your character. That you can buy, for real money, since a full retcon is incredibly expensive using the regular in-game currency.

Now, here’s my problem with the whole thing. I understand why a full retcon is expensive inside the game – it’s a prohibitive cost so that players won’t respecc all the time. It’s a design choice made by the developers, it sends a clear message of the consequences associated with picking your powers. It also frustrates flavor-of-the-month players and min/maxers, which I find funny. I can see where the system goes wrong, especially in a game which has too many powers to balance against each other, but hey – I get it.

By adding the option to buy your way out of this by using your credit card, it feels like Cryptic are saying that the design isn’t that important anyway. Sure, 1000 Champion Points cost $12.50/€10.88, so the cost can still be seen as prohibitive. But the cost outside of the game doesn’t really matter, it’s the effect on gameplay. And obviously full retcons aren’t that much of a deal after all. So why are they still so expensive inside the game?

This t-shirt speaks the truth.

This t-shirt speaks the truth.

The second thing is that in Champions Online, you are able to gimp your character by choosing the wrong combination of powers. If you are unlucky, you run the risk of finding a build that either is really hard to play, impossible to use for anything, or utterly worthless in PvP. Depending on your style of play, or if you shift your style of play, you might want to consider a retcon. At that point you have three choices – find the in-game currency to pay for it, pay 1000 CPs and get one straight away or take it like a man/woman and reroll.

The third problem I can see with adding a retcon to the Champions Store is what this might mean for the future development of the title. What if a new producer steps up after Roper and identifies the high cost of retconning as a major problem and wants to take it out? What if that is actually the right choice, compared to how expensive they are now? (I’m not saying that’s the case, it’s hypothetical.) How would Cryptic be able to make that change without majorly upsetting the players who have actually paid that money already?

Cryptic has already been giving out free retcons before, after major patches been made to powers. Will that ever happen again?

The whole thing is a serpent’s nest of potential conflict between Cryptic and the players. And I’ve lost all faith in that the devs have any clue what they are doing. I am not saying that this is all a conspiracy, that this has been planned all along and that prices of retcons in-game was kept high to pave the way for the C-store option. Neither am I saying that this will “kill” Champions Online, I think the retcon will sell and probably quite well. I’m not all gloom and doom.

But I do believe that the current development team is showing signs of being completely lost in the woods. Perhaps Bill Roper is to blame, I don’t know. And perhaps they really should consider what kind of game they are offering here – is it a free-to-play MMO with a fully stocked item shop, or a subscription based game where what happens in the game stays in the game?

Again, feel free to point out things I’ve misunderstood or missed. I am no longer playing Champions Online and I have no intention of logging in either. But please, please, don’t come dragging the age old “if you don’t like it, don’t use it”, since that’s not what this entry is about. If I were playing CO, I would have no problem with the people buying the retcons. That’s not what this entry is about – it’s about what kind of message this sends, or the consequences it can have.

Digg This
Reddit This
Stumble Now!
Buzz This
Vote on DZone
Share on Facebook
Bookmark this on Delicious
Kick It on
Shout it
Share on LinkedIn
Bookmark this on Technorati
Post on Twitter
Google Buzz (aka. Google Reader)


  1. Scopique says:

    I think it’s opportunistic. They threw it in there because they could, knowing that there will probably be people who will be wanting a retcon, can’t afford the in-game price, and will welcome another “avenue” of access. However, I agree that it’s pretty shameless: why charge real money when the same option is available in game, but is priced to seem as if the devs are DRIVING people to view the RMT method as the “more accessable option”?

    Were the option not in the game with in-game currency, I would think that it’s par for the MMO course. It might even be the start of a trend from here on in, but having the dueling options just looks overtly greedy.

  2. Petter says:

    Oh, yes. It could be greed. But I wonder who is pulling the strings there – it might be Atari that is pushing Cryptic, if greed is the reason. Which doesn’t bode well for the game, I suppose.

    In either case, it certainly looks opportunistic. It would’ve been a much better idea to fix the system first, make sure everyone is more or less happy with it, then offer it. This is way too early, at least from what I have understood of the whole thing.

  3. Longasc says:

    Champions is quite instanced. So why does it need fixed power sets. Guild Wars allows players to totally re-adjust their char attributes and their skill selection, “build” in Guild Wars lingo.

    People were scared that it takes away from the ingame “character” and immersion if he can change from Swordsman to Axeman or change his secondary class on the fly, they were scared of a lot of things. I was quite sceptical about this, too.

    A few weeks later nobody could imagine not being able to respec without restrictions anymore at all. So much about that.

    Champions is digging it’s own grave. I guess they would keep more subscribers by allowing easier respecs than they make money from selling respecs. I think it would only be good and send a clear message to the industry if people get pissed off by this and just quit the game.

  4. Mark says:

    I think the retcon in the store is FINE AS LONG AS you can run a very difficult mission or series of missions to achieve the same thing. City of Heroes has the Terra Volta Respec Trial. So far, it looks like UNITY Merits can be used for cute action figures but maybe retcons could be added to this system. I’d prefer something unique however to keep things more interesting.

    As long as XP potions never show up in the Champions Store, I’m fine with it.

  5. Jeremy says:

    Wait, 13 real american dollars to respec a character out? Plus you’re paying a monthly fee? Wow. That’s all. Wow.

  6. Muckbeast says:

    > It also frustrates flavor-of-the-month players and
    > min/maxers, which I find funny.

    That couldn’t be further from the truth. Min/Maxers already know what powers to pick in advance. And if the devs nerf something, they powerlevel up a new max level character in no time.

    In fact, serious powergamers LOVE IT when a game lacks respecs and has devs who like to nerf stuff. They know they are the ones who can level up a new character faster than everyone else, and then have more time being “uber” compared to the masses.

    It is a common misconception that min/maxers are the ones begging for retcons. But the truth is, retcons are far more needed for “normal players” who make all sorts of mistakes. These are the types of people who just play the game. They don’t read forums, they don’t use character builders, they don’t do 300 hours of research.

  7. Petter says:

    That’s a very good point, Muck. :)

  8. Having reached level 11 and realised that I have made some silly decisions, the cost of a retcon seems very expensive. I know some will say that re-rolling to level 11 is just a few hours and I would agree. The issue there is not everyone can facilitate another ‘x’ hours through the same quests to reach the same point.

    As it’s a mmo based on a monthly fee, it would not seem unreasonable for Cryptic to provide 1 free (non-stacking) retcon with every new month’s subscription. This way if you make a poor build, you have a penalty of the rest of the sub month to suffer.. OR you can pay the cost ingame or stump the cash with real money.

    This would seem a fair approach to a game that provides so much versatility but at the same time, so little flexibility.

  9. Zergor says:

    The thing that irks me, is that I said, oh I’ll just save up in game money to retcon, and I go to the shop several levels later and the cost has increased vastly faster than I earned in game money. So … basically it raises as you get more money, pushing you to the $13 store version. Very skanky IMO.

Copyright © Don’t Fear the Mutant
Virtual worlds, massive multiplayer games and assorted ramblings

Built on Notes Blog Core
Powered by WordPress